This test is seriously flawed. This only tests the browser performance in combination with the processing hardware. Do all three browsers support the same technologies, like Javascript, Flash, etc? Don’t you think the iPhone’s and Droid’s faster processors give it an advantage over the anemic G1?

Wouldn’t a test using common devices have been a little better? Or how about tethering to a desktop OS and using a browser based speed test? I’ve seen the iPhone 3GS’ simplistic browser render pages faster on 3G than the N95 browser on WiFi, so this test’s data is worth little if any at all. I’ve also seen the latest speed test data floating around, and TMobileUSA seems to have lept past at&t’s data speeds exponentially, and even was faster than Verizon and Sprint in many cases.

Can we get a retest using the phones tethered to a device? And maybe use a HTC TP2 or some other device that all three carriers have with similar configuration. This unscientific test gives nothing but browser rendering results. And give the location of the test, and maybe ask others in the community from other locations to copy the test.

This is stupid test.
There are too many variables and none of them are controlled across the series of devices. Any conclusion made about the comparison of network speed is bogus.

Pull up one of your old science books from grade school or at least Google the scientific method before you conduct any more tests and waste your readers’ time.

Mr. Mark, are there not variables in your day to day life that affect your phone? Maybe you use your phone only under the most perfect measurable conditions ha? Your variables sound a lot like excuses. As for the rest of the world, we have variables in our day to day lives. It is the ability of the phones to produce in the “real world” and not some “perfect environment” that is going to sell the product. So how about you pull out your old science books and read up on “practical application”.